Sitemaps

What is the better choice as per the criteria given below, as a pet dog: German Shephard or Boxer2007-11-25 2:52:36

While I love both breeds, I'd recommend the boxer.

---

Because you specifically mention warm weather in your question, the GS would be the better choice. Because of their nasal shape, Boxers would have more difficulty with heat. If that was not a serious concern, however, I would select the Boxer hands down.

---

I live in the an area that has a lot of warm weather and was a veterinary technician for 7 years, before I became a stay at home mom. I would go with a Boxer they are great with kids, and would probably shed less than a German Shepard due to warm weather. The vet I used to work for raised Boxers and was a part of Boxer rescue. None of her dogs had breathing problems due to the heat.

---

I like the boxer.

---

Let's address the guard dog issue, first.

Forget it. You will be better served with a good alarm system that ties into the local police/fire/rescue units than a guard dog - and your homeowners insurance will probably go down.

If you have a "guard dog" you will more than likely lose your homeowner's insurance because of the liability issue with a guard dog. And even if you get rid of the dog - no insurance company would issue you a policy you can afford because you once had a guard dog. That's how it is and how it's going to be.

So drop that idea right here and now.

Both breeds are a good choice for a family dog. Both Boxers and Shepherds are sweet-natured and loyal. Both are "active" meaning that they need a lot of exercise. That may be an issue concerning very small children (under 6) and elderly people who may not be able to keep up with an energetic puppy.